UCSB 93106 Public Affairs Back Issues Contact
Study: Dropouts Cost State $46.4 Billion


California Dropout Research Project Director Russell Rumberger gets help from graduate students Susan Rotermund, left, and Sun Ah Lim.



California’s high school dropouts cost state taxpayers approximately $46.4 billion annually, according to a recent study by the UCSB-based California Dropout Research Project (CDRP) at UC’s Linguistic Minority Research Institute. In addition, the authors estimate that the economic benefit from effective dropout intervention programs could be as much as $392,000 for each high school graduate.
“Until now, we knew very little about the economic costs of California’s dropout crisis,” said Russell W. Rumberger, professor at the Gevirtz Graduate School of Education and UCSB’s director of the CDRP. “These findings reveal severe economic consequences to the state and underscore the need for solutions to the dropout crisis.”
The crisis stems from the 120,000 Californians who reach age 20 each year without a high school diploma. Over a lifetime, that group of dropouts will cost the state $46.4 billion dollars, according to the studies’ authors Henry M. Levin, Columbia University professor of economics, and Clive Belfield, assistant professor of economics from Queens College, City University of New York.
CDRP director Rumberger says dropouts’ fiscal impact comes in the form of lost tax revenues, medical costs, and the increased likelihood of being on welfare or committing a crime.
Specifically, the project’s first policy brief, titled “The Economic Losses From High School Dropouts in California,” concludes: California loses $46.4 billion—2.9 percent of the gross state product—for each cohort of Californians who reach age 20 without a high school diploma. High school graduates earn an average of $290,000 more during their lifetime and pay $100,000 more in taxes than dropouts. State and local government loses $3.1 billion in tax revenue for each cohort of dropouts.
High school graduation reduces violent crime by 20 percent, property crime by 11 percent and drug-related offenses by 12 percent. California loses $2.5 billion in crime expenditures for each cohort. More than two-thirds of dropouts use food stamps during their lifetime, and high school graduates are 68 percent less likely to be on welfare.
Dropouts have a higher risk of stroke, heart disease, diabetes, depression, and other serious conditions. State and local government loses $3.5 billion in health expenditures for each cohort. For more details, visit the CDRP Web site at: <http://lmri.ucsb.edu/dropouts>.
The project’s second policy brief, “The Return on Investment for Improving California’s High School Graduation Rate,” explores the cost of proven dropout intervention programs around the United States. The brief’s authors found that the cost of using these programs to keep a student in school is far less than a dropout’s lifetime burden on the state.
Researchers uncovered five intervention programs with proven records of success, and estimated their costs at anywhere from $37,810 to $131,000 per graduate. The project estimates a total economic benefit of $392,000 when a potential California dropout stays in school and earns a diploma. Based on those figures, there would be at least a $3 return on every $1 invested in dropout prevention in California.
“If similar intervention programs could be implemented in California at similar costs, they would certainly prove to be worthwhile investments for the state,” Rumberger said.
Over the next six months, CDRP will issue a series of additional research reports and statistical briefs that further study the economic and social costs of dropouts and explore potential solutions.
CDRP is funded by $850,000 in grants from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, the James Irvine Foundation, the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, and the Walter S. Johnson Foundation.

—George Yatchisin & Kent Barrett